The project is complete. Last CD ripped into iTunes: U2 "Please" (the single.) Now our entire library of CDs is sync-able to our iPod.
Oh, did I mention that we got a new iPod? After a couple of great years of service, our 40GB iPod photo gave up the ghost with a clicking hard drive. We decided to replace it with the new 80GB 5.5 generation model. It's so pretty. Right now, we have 34.43 GB of music on it.
Also, I got a deal on Toast 8, so we can move Tivo shows to the iPod. Look for the other 40GB-ish (after formatting) to be filled up quick.